Leadership survey questions to build stronger leaders

Last Updated October 30, 2026 | 21 min read
|

Leadership survey questions are the items you put to employees about the people who manage them, so you can find out what it’s like to work for a given leader before the exit interviews tell you. Most organizations already have an opinion on every manager. It lives in the hallway and almost never gets written down, and the person it’s about is the last to hear it.

Say you run HR for a company with 40 managers. Two of them have teams that keep quitting, and you’ve known that for a year. What you haven’t got is anything you can put in front of either of them that isn’t a complaint from a named employee or a number from the turnover report. A leadership survey gives you the sentence in between: here’s what your team said, here’s how it compares with the other 38, and here’s where to start.

The question banks come first: effectiveness items, then employee survey questions about leadership in general, then communication. After those comes a leadership questionnaire for managers broken out by skill. The build steps and the analysis sit at the end, since the hard part starts once the responses are in.

Key takeaways

  • A leadership survey works when it asks about behaviors a direct report can see. “My manager explains the reasoning behind decisions” gets you something to act on. “My manager is a good leader” gets you a mood.
  • If employees aren’t convinced the survey is anonymous, you’ll get polite 4s across the board and learn nothing. Response thresholds and a named owner for the data do more for honesty than any wording tweak.
  • You don’t need 50 questions. Picture 15 to 25 items, five minutes, with the open-text box optional. The longer form gets abandoned on question 30 by the people whose answers you most needed.
  • Scores mean little on their own. The gap between how a manager rates herself and how her team rates her is where the coaching conversation lives, and that gap only shows up when you ask both sides the same questions.

What is a leadership survey?

A leadership survey is a structured questionnaire that asks employees to rate specific, observable behaviors of the people who lead them, usually on a 5-point agreement scale, with results reported by team once enough people have answered. The word to hold on to is observable. A direct report can tell you whether her manager gave her a straight answer about the reorg last month. She can’t tell you whether he has “strategic vision,” and asking her to try produces a number that means nothing.

Leadership surveys come in a few shapes, and they get confused with each other in meetings. An upward feedback survey goes from direct reports to one manager. A 360-degree feedback program adds the manager’s own self-rating and the views of her peers and her own boss, then reports the gaps between them. A leadership pulse goes to the whole company and asks about senior leadership as a group rather than any one person. The questions overlap heavily across all three. The reporting and the anonymity rules are what differ.

Picture a hospital system with 300 nurse managers. An upward survey tells each one what her unit thinks. A 360 tells her where she and her unit disagree, which is usually the more useful fact. The company-wide pulse tells the chief nursing officer whether “leadership communicates openly” has moved since the last round of budget cuts. Three different reports, built from mostly the same items.

Why leadership surveys matter for organizational growth?

People quit managers before they quit companies, and the manager is almost always the last to know. The warning signs sit with the team for months: the standup where nobody volunteers anything, the project that goes quiet, the strong performer who starts leaving at five. A leadership survey gets those signals onto paper while the people giving them still work for you.

The second reason is the gap between how leaders think things are going and how everyone else does. The Sogolytics Experience Index: Employee Edition (EX) 2026 found that 45% of executives call their organization very transparent, against 14% of frontline employees. That’s a 31-point gap on the same question in the same companies. Nobody closes it by announcing more transparency from the stage. It closes when managers find out, team by team, what their own people think is being hidden.

What a decent program gets you:

  • Named development areas per manager, in the words of the people who report to them, which is a different thing from a generic leadership course
  • Early warning on the two or three teams where scores have dropped since the last cycle, before the resignations arrive
  • A view across managers, so you can see whether “explains decisions” is a company problem or a Dave problem
  • Evidence for promotion and succession decisions beyond the candidate’s own results
  • Something to show the board when they ask whether the leadership development budget did anything

Suppose a regional bank runs the survey for the first time and finds 31 of its 40 branch managers score fine on most items and poorly on one: “my manager tells me when something I did went well.” That’s a company habit, and it gets fixed with a company-wide nudge. The nine managers who score poorly across the board are a different conversation, and now you know which nine. Employee leadership development programs tend to work far better when they start from a list like that. Developing Potential, a leadership consultancy in England, moved its client survey work onto Sogolytics for the same reason: paper surveys capped how many organizations it could run this kind of exercise for.

See every manager’s scores without exposing anyone
Manager-specific dashboards, configurable anonymity thresholds, and trend tracking by team in one employee survey platform.

Leadership effectiveness survey questions to evaluate performance

These leadership survey questions measure how well a manager does the job, as seen by the people doing the work. Each item names one behavior. If you find yourself writing “my manager is effective,” split it into the three or four things effective looks like on a Tuesday afternoon, and ask those instead.

Score every item 1 to 5 (strongly disagree to strongly agree) and add a “don’t know” option. A new hire of three weeks has no basis for rating her manager’s handling of conflict, and without a way to say so she’ll pick a 3 and muddy the average.

  • My manager sets clear priorities for our team.
  • I understand what my manager expects of me in this role.
  • My manager removes obstacles that slow my work down.
  • When my manager commits to something, it gets done.
  • My manager makes decisions in a reasonable amount of time.
  • My manager holds everyone on the team to the same standards.
  • My manager gives me useful feedback on my work at least once a month.
  • My manager tells me when something I did went well.
  • My manager addresses performance problems on the team rather than letting them slide.
  • My manager helps me understand how my work connects to the organization’s goals.
  • My manager is available when I need a decision or input.
  • I would recommend my manager to a colleague looking to join a new team.

Item 12 is a manager NPS of sorts. It won’t tell you what’s wrong, but trended by manager across two cycles it tells you where to look first.

DimensionItems aboveWhat a low score usually meansFirst thing to check
Clarity and direction1, 2, 10The team is guessing at prioritiesWhether goals exist in writing anywhere the team can see them
Execution and follow-through3, 4, 5, 11Decisions stall or get reversedManager’s own workload and how many approvals sit with one person
Fairness and standards6, 9One or two people get a passWhether the manager has had a difficult conversation this quarter
Feedback and recognition7, 8People hear from the manager only when something breaksFrequency of one-to-ones, and whether they happen at all
Advocacy12Everything above, taken togetherCompare with turnover and internal transfer requests for that team

Employee survey questions about leadership and management

Employee survey questions about leadership look past the direct manager at the people running the place. These go to everyone, they ask about senior leadership as a group, and the answers tell you whether the strategy memo landed anywhere below the vice president level. Keep the wording about “senior leadership” or “the leadership team” so nobody is rating a person they’ve met twice.

The same scale applies. Two or three of these items belong on every engagement survey, since employee engagement measurement that skips leadership tends to find the symptom and miss the cause.

  • Senior leadership has communicated a clear direction for the organization.
  • I understand how my team’s work supports that direction.
  • Senior leadership keeps us informed about changes that affect our work before they happen.
  • When leadership asks for employee feedback, something changes as a result.
  • Leadership’s decisions reflect the values this organization says it holds.
  • I trust senior leadership to make the right calls for the organization’s future.
  • Leaders here admit mistakes rather than covering them.
  • Senior leadership is visible and approachable, not only at all-hands meetings.
  • Different departments get consistent messages from leadership.
  • I have confidence in the people who will be leading this organization in three years.

Item 4 is the one to watch. The EX Index found only 10% of employees say their feedback always leads to change, and a leadership survey that scores low on this item has told you what will happen to its own results if nobody acts on them.

Leadership communication survey questions to improve team collaboration

Communication is where leadership surveys find the most movement, because it’s the part of leadership a team experiences every day. Picture a manager who is a sound decision-maker and a fair one, and who never says why. Her team scores her well on fairness and badly on everything else, because they can’t see the reasoning, so the decisions look arbitrary. These items separate what a manager decided from how it reached the team.

  • My manager explains the reasoning behind decisions that affect my work.
  • I hear about changes to my team’s priorities from my manager before I hear about them elsewhere.
  • My manager listens to understand my point of view before responding.
  • I can raise a concern with my manager without worrying about how it will affect me.
  • My manager gives difficult messages directly rather than hinting or delaying.
  • Our team meetings have a clear purpose and end with decisions or next steps.
  • My manager shares what she or he learns in leadership meetings that’s relevant to our work.
  • My manager encourages people on the team to speak up when they disagree.
  • When I send my manager a question, I get an answer within a reasonable time.
  • My manager adapts how she or he communicates to what the situation needs, in writing or in person.

If scores on items 2 and 7 are low across most managers, the problem probably sits one level up, with information not reaching managers in time to pass on. An internal communication audit is the next step there, and the fix is rarely a training course for the managers.

The Sogolytics Experience Index: Employee Edition, Q3 2026
What 1,000 US employees said about anonymous feedback, which roles trust it, and how worries about AI at work have shifted.

Leadership questionnaire for managers: questions by skill and competency

A leadership questionnaire for managers goes deeper than the general items above, and it works best as part of a 360, where the manager answers the same questions about herself. Group the items by competency so the report can say “strong on decisions, weak on empowerment” rather than handing back 30 undifferentiated scores. The three groups below cover the competencies that come up in nearly every leadership framework. Swap in your own labels if your organization has them.

The direct reports see “my manager.” The manager sees “I.” Keep the behavior in each item identical across both versions, or the gap you measure is a wording artifact.

Questions about decision-making and problem-solving

  • My manager gathers input from the people affected before making significant decisions.
  • My manager makes decisions with the information available rather than waiting for certainty.
  • Once a decision is made, my manager explains it and stands behind it.
  • My manager changes course when the evidence says the first call was wrong.
  • When problems arise, my manager focuses on fixing them rather than on who caused them.
  • My manager breaks large problems into pieces the team can work on.

Questions about employee support and empowerment

  • My manager gives me the authority to make decisions in my own area of work.
  • My manager backs me up when I make a reasonable decision that doesn’t work out.
  • My manager helps me develop skills that will matter for my next role, not only my current one.
  • My manager notices when my workload is unsustainable and does something about it.
  • My manager connects me with people and resources outside the team when I need them.
  • My manager gives me stretch assignments that match what I’ve said I want to learn.

Questions about trust, accountability, and transparency

  • My manager does what she or he says she or he will do.
  • My manager shares information openly, including news the team won’t like.
  • My manager takes responsibility when things go wrong on the team rather than passing it down.
  • My manager treats what I share in confidence as confidential.
  • My manager gives credit to the people who did the work.
  • My manager applies the same rules to herself or himself as to the rest of us.
CompetencyStrongest signal itemsTypical self-versus-team gapWhat the gap usually means
Decision-makingGathers input; explains and stands behind decisionsManager rates herself higher on gathering inputInput is being gathered from the same two people every time
Problem-solvingFixes rather than blames; breaks problems downSmall gap in most casesThis competency tends to be visible to everyone, so the views line up
Support and empowermentBacks up decisions; notices workloadManager rates herself much higher on noticing workloadThe manager sees hours worked, the team feels the Sunday-night emails
Trust and accountabilityDoes what she says; takes responsibilityTeam rates the manager higher than she rates herselfCommon for newer managers, and worth telling them
TransparencyShares unwelcome news; gives creditManager rates herself higher on sharing newsBad news is being filtered on the way down, often with good intentions

For a fuller item bank built for the self-plus-others format, the 360 degree appraisal questions guide covers peers and skip-levels too.

How Archbright cut client report time from 13 hours to 1
An HR services provider automated employee surveys across email, SMS, and kiosk, and gave clients live report links.

How to create a leadership survey for employees and managers?

Decide the scope first
The scope gets decided before any question is written. Say you’ve got 40 managers. Running all 40 in the first cycle means 40 difficult conversations in the same month, and HR can’t support that many at once. Picture starting with the 12 directors, who then run it for their own managers next quarter with the benefit of having been on the receiving end.

Cut the item list to 20
The item list gets cut to 20 or fewer. Pull from the banks above, keep two or three items per competency, and add one open question: “What is one thing your manager could do differently that would make the biggest difference to you?” A 16-item manager effectiveness survey template takes about six minutes, which is the right neighborhood.

Define anonymity in writing
Anonymity gets defined in writing and stated in the invitation. Responses are collected without names. Reports open only once a minimum number of direct reports has answered, and a team of two never becomes a report at all. Write the threshold into the invitation email, because employees who have been burned before will look for it.

Mirror the team version for managers
The manager version mirrors the team version word for word. “My manager explains the reasoning behind decisions” becomes “I explain the reasoning behind my decisions.” In Sogolytics, the 360 program lets you choose rater groups per program, so the self-rating and the direct-report rating sit in the same project and the gap report builds itself.

Run distribution for two weeks
Distribution runs for two weeks, with reminders that don’t reveal who has answered. Email covers office staff. Shift workers, drivers, and anyone without a company inbox need SMS or a QR code on the break-room notice board, or the survey measures only the opinions of people with desks.

Write down the reporting rules
The reporting rules get written down. Who sees an individual manager’s report: the manager, her own manager, and HR. Who sees the cohort view: HR and the executive team, by division, never by name below a threshold. Picture the moment a vice president asks to see a specific director’s raw comments. The rule has to exist before that moment, since it won’t survive being invented during it.

Pilot with one division first
A pilot goes to one friendly division first. Twenty responses will tell you whether item 7 reads as two questions and whether anyone understood “stretch assignment.” Fix the wording, then go wide.

Building the survey takes an afternoon. Deciding who sees what takes longer, and that decision is where leadership surveys succeed or quietly fail. The steps below assume you’re running an upward survey with an optional self-rating, which is where most organizations start before moving to a full 360.

How to analyze leadership survey results and take action?

Start with the item-level view
The item-level view comes before any overall score. Sort every manager’s results by item, lowest first. The bottom two items are the coaching agenda, and for most managers they’ll be obvious the moment you read them aloud.

Compare each manager with the company pattern
Each manager’s profile gets compared with the company pattern. If 30 of 40 managers score low on “tells me when something went well,” that’s a culture gap, and the fix is a company-wide expectation rather than 30 separate coaching plans. The items where a manager sits well below the cohort are hers alone.

Read self-versus-team gaps
Self-versus-team gaps get read where a self-rating exists. A manager who rates herself 5 on listening while her team gives her 2.8 has a blind spot, and the report should say so plainly. The reverse gap, where the team rates her higher than she rates herself, is worth telling her too, because newer managers often carry it and it holds them back.

Group open comments into themes
Open comments get grouped into themes. Say 200 comments come back across the company. Grouping them by theme and reading the sentiment on each turns them into five or six patterns, and the themes for one manager can go into her report without exposing who wrote what.

Give each manager a plan and date
Each manager gets a conversation, a plan, and a date. The conversation covers two strengths and two development items, with the team’s own words where the threshold allows. The plan has an owner and a due date, and it carries over to the next cycle so progress can be measured rather than remembered.

Report back to the team within three weeks
Results go back to the team within three weeks. Picture a manager standing in front of her team and saying, “You told me I don’t explain decisions. Here’s what I’m going to do about it, and here’s how you’ll know.” That one meeting does more for next cycle’s response rate than any reminder email.

Schedule the next cycle now
The next cycle gets scheduled before this one is forgotten. Six to twelve months out, same items, so the comparison holds. The question for cycle two is whether the two development items moved, and nothing else matters as much.

Score patternWhat it points toActionWho owns it
Low on one or two items, fine elsewhereA specific habit, probably fixableCoaching conversation on those items; check in at 90 daysManager’s own manager
Low across most items, one teamA manager in the wrong role, or in troubleStructured support plan with a decision point; review turnover for the teamHR with the manager’s manager
Low on the same item across many managersA culture or system gapCompany-wide expectation and training, tracked on the next cycleHR and executive team
High self-rating, low team rating on an itemA blind spotShare the gap directly with examples from comments; revisit next cycleManager’s own manager
Low team rating, lower self-ratingAwareness without supportDevelopment resources and a mentor; the manager already knowsHR
Low scores on “feedback leads to change”The survey program itself is losing credibilityPublish what changed after the last cycle before launching the nextProgram owner

Treat a single bad cycle with some care, though. One low score could be a bad quarter, or a team that lost two people in a month. Two cycles in the same direction is a pattern, and the employee performance management record for that team will usually tell you which it was.

Conclusion

A leadership survey earns its place when each manager leaves the cycle with two specific behaviors to work on and the team can see, six months later, whether anything moved. Sogolytics’ 360 degree feedback program handles the parts that usually break a leadership survey: rater groups per program, reports that stay closed until the response threshold is met, self-versus-others gaps flagged in the report, and development plans with owners and due dates that carry over to the next cycle.

Turn leadership feedback into development plans that stick
Assign owners and due dates, schedule reviews, and carry each manager’s plan into the next cycle automatically.

FAQs about leadership survey questions

How many questions should a leadership survey include?

Fifteen to twenty-five scored items plus one open question, which keeps the survey under seven minutes for most people. Picture a nurse filling it in on her phone between shifts; she’ll finish 20 items and abandon 45. The 16-item manager effectiveness template takes about six minutes and is a reasonable starting point to cut down from.

Should leadership survey questions be anonymous?

Only 29% of frontline employees are confident that feedback stays anonymous, against 66% of executives, according to The Sogolytics Experience Index: Employee Edition Q3 2026, so stating a response threshold (reports open at five responses, say) does more than the word “anonymous” on its own.

Which rating scale works best for leadership surveys?

A 5-point agreement scale, strongly disagree to strongly agree, with a separate “don’t know” option. Five points give you enough spread to see movement between cycles without asking people to tell a 7 from an 8. The “don’t know” matters more than it looks, because a new hire who can’t yet judge her manager’s handling of conflict will otherwise pick the middle and flatten the average.

How often should organizations conduct leadership surveys?

Once a year for a full leadership survey or 360, with a short pulse at the six-month mark on the two or three items each manager is working on. Annual keeps the comparison clean and gives development plans time to show up in the scores. Running the full survey more often than that tends to produce fatigue before it produces change, and the pulse survey questions format covers the in-between check without the full load.

How should managers communicate leadership survey results to employees?

In person and within three weeks, covering two strengths and two things the manager intends to change. Picture the manager saying, “You told me I don’t explain decisions, so from next week every priority change comes with the reason attached, and you can hold me to that.” The team learns the survey was read, and next cycle’s response rate takes care of itself.

What should managers do when leadership survey feedback is negative?

Read it twice, then wait a day before responding to anyone. A low score on one item is a habit to change and usually a quick one; low scores across the board call for a conversation with the manager’s own manager about support, and a plan with dates attached. What a manager should never do is go looking for who wrote what, since the one thing that guarantees worse scores next cycle is a team that learns the anonymity promise was hollow.

SHARE:

See what your feedback data is already telling you. Request a Demo

Client

Company Size

Industries

Customer Since

Read more

Typical Rave Review

Description