Peer review questions for employees examples

Last Updated October 30, 2026 | 18 min read
|

Peer review questions are the prompts you give coworkers so they can rate and describe how a colleague works day to day. You’ve probably filled in a weak one. It says “Any comments on Sam?” and you type “Sam’s great” because it’s 4:55 on a Friday.

Most reviews still rest on one manager’s view. That view has holes. Your manager saw the finished report land on time. Dana, who sits next to you, saw the two late nights. She also saw the shortcut that broke the build that Friday. Peer feedback questions, written well, get Dana’s version onto the page without turning the review into a popularity contest.

The question bank comes first: more than 45 peer review questions for employees, grouped by what peers can see. After that you’ll find how to write your own peer review questionnaire, then how to run one in Sogolytics.

Key takeaways

  • Your stand-up, yes. Your strategy deck, probably not. Peers can rate what they’ve watched, and the strategy question belongs to your manager anyway.
  • Three or four rating items and one text box per category is about right. That’s enough to see a trend, and the text box is where someone explains why they gave a 2.
  • Hidden names change what people are willing to write. So does a report that stays locked until enough peers have answered; without that, expect a lot of “great to work with.”
  • You get the most from peer input when it sits beside the self-review and the manager’s view. The gaps between the three are usually the useful part.

What is peer feedback?

Peer feedback is your coworkers’ take on how you work. Mostly it comes from people at your level who share your projects. It’s the analyst who checks your numbers before finance sees them. It’s also the designer you’ve sat beside in every sprint planning since March. Neither of them manages you. With no say over your raise, they tend to talk about how the work got done.

Some companies collect it once a year inside the formal review. Others send a five-question peer review survey the week a project ships, while memories are fresh. Plenty do both. The format matters less than what happens after, because someone has to read it with the employee and decide what changes.

Two other sources usually sit beside it. A self-evaluation questionnaire is the employee’s own read on their year. 360 degree appraisal questions go wider and pull in managers and direct reports as well as peers. Of the lot, peer comments tend to land hardest, since they describe moments the employee didn’t know anyone noticed.

Say a support lead thinks she’s the calm one on escalations. Her manager agrees; her tickets close on time. Three peers, though, mention the same thing. When a customer threatens to cancel, she stops answering the team chat for an hour. Nobody outside the queue would ever have seen it.

Why effective peer review questions matter for employee development?

Ask a peer “Is Jordan a good teammate?” and you’ll get “yes,” maybe “yes, definitely.” Jordan can’t do much with that. Change it to “How does Jordan respond when someone needs help an hour before a deadline?” and the reviewer starts remembering last Thursday, when Jordan dropped her own ticket to help. That’s something Jordan can keep doing on purpose.

Reviews could use the help. Gallup asked employees about this in 2017, and only 14% strongly agreed that the performance reviews they received inspired them to improve. Peers won’t fix that on their own. What they bring is evidence from people who were there, and a review built on what someone saw is harder to dismiss as one manager’s opinion.

[Source: https://www.gallup.com/workplace/236135/give-performance-reviews-actually-inspire-employees.aspx]

Good peer review questions turn up things a manager rarely sees:

  • Blind spots, like the habit of finishing other people’s sentences in meetings
  • A second opinion on the manager’s rating, from people who were in the room
  • Quiet contributors whose work never shows up on a dashboard but holds up everyone else’s
  • Early warnings about friction between teammates, months before it turns into a resignation letter
  • Real examples the employee can build a development plan around

None of it matters if the answers vanish. Picture a team that fills in peer reviews every spring and never hears about them again. By year three, people type “no concerns” and close the tab. Who’d blame them? That’s the real cost of employee feedback without action.

Peer review questions for employees by category

You won’t need all of these at once. Picture Marco in accounts payable, asked to rate a colleague on 40 questions the week before quarter close. He’ll answer the first 20 properly. After that it’s 4, 4, 4, submit. Two or three categories per review keeps him honest. Anything marked (rating) goes on a five-point scale, and anything marked (open-ended) gets a text box. Swap in the person’s name where it says “this colleague,” since people write more about Priya than about a placeholder.

Peer-to-peer feedback questions about teamwork and collaboration

Collaboration is where peers have the best view. They’re the ones on the other end of the handoff.

  • How often does this colleague offer help when a teammate is behind? (rating)
  • How reliably does this colleague share information the team needs to do its work? (rating)
  • How well does this colleague handle disagreements about how work should be done? (rating)
  • How often does this colleague give credit to others for shared results? (rating)
  • How open is this colleague to ideas that differ from their own? (rating)
  • How easy is it to work with this colleague on a project with a tight deadline? (rating)
  • Describe a time this colleague made a group project easier for everyone. (open-ended)
  • What’s one thing this colleague could do to make collaboration with them smoother? (open-ended)

Want to rate the team itself? That’s a different survey, and a team evaluation survey covers group dynamics and decision-making, while the questions above stay on one person.

Peer evaluation questions about communication skills

You won’t see communication problems in output metrics. Picture an analyst, call her Mei, whose reports are accurate and always on time. She sends them at 11 p.m. with no summary. The next morning three teammates are scrolling through tabs trying to work out what changed. Her manager? He sees a report that arrived on time.

  • How clearly does this colleague explain their ideas in meetings? (rating)
  • How clear and complete are this colleague’s written updates, such as emails, chat messages and reports? (rating)
  • How well does this colleague listen before responding? (rating)
  • How promptly does this colleague reply when you need information from them? (rating)
  • How well does this colleague adjust their message for different audiences, such as clients or other departments? (rating)
  • How comfortable do you feel raising a concern with this colleague? (rating)
  • What’s one thing this colleague does that makes their communication easy to follow? (open-ended)
  • Is there a situation where a clearer message from this colleague would have saved you time? Please describe it. (open-ended)

Peer review questions for employees about performance and reliability

Peers are often next in line for someone’s work. If a handoff arrives on Friday afternoon instead of Wednesday, they’re the ones who stay late. Leave the big question of overall job performance to the manager and keep these to handoffs and promises.

  • How often does this colleague meet the deadlines they commit to? (rating)
  • How would you rate the quality of the work this colleague hands off to you? (rating)
  • How often do you need to follow up with this colleague to get something done? (rating)
  • How well does this colleague keep the team informed when a task is going to be late? (rating)
  • How consistently does this colleague follow agreed processes and standards? (rating)
  • How well does this colleague handle an unexpected problem without stalling the team? (rating)
  • Describe a time this colleague’s work made your job easier. (open-ended)
  • If this colleague missed a commitment, how did they handle it? (open-ended)

Your managers will want their own set for the other half of the review. There’s a separate list of employee performance evaluation questions for that half, built around goals and output and the role-specific skills peers aren’t placed to judge.

Peer feedback questions about strengths and areas for improvement

People go easy on colleagues they like. If the form asks for “weaknesses,” Lisa from finance writes “works too hard” about Tom and moves on. Ask her what would help Tom be even more effective, and she’ll tell you he never hands anything off. That’s the same weakness. She didn’t have to call it one.

  • What do you see as this colleague’s greatest strength at work? (open-ended)
  • When would you go to this colleague first for help, and why? (open-ended)
  • Which skill, if this colleague developed it further, would make the biggest difference to the team? (open-ended)
  • What would help this colleague be even more effective in their role? (open-ended)
  • How well does this colleague act on feedback they’ve received? (rating)
  • How well does this colleague’s strongest skill show up in team projects? (rating)
  • Has this colleague grown in any area over the past six months? Please give an example. (open-ended)

Open-ended peer review questions for constructive feedback

Text boxes are where the detail lives. They’re also slow to fill in. Pick three or four from this list for any one form, because a reviewer rating eight colleagues will be typing “N/A” by the fifth.

  • What should this colleague start doing?
  • What should this colleague stop doing?
  • What should this colleague keep doing?
  • Describe a recent situation where this colleague handled something well.
  • Describe a recent situation where a different approach from this colleague would have helped the team.
  • What’s one piece of advice you’d give this colleague for the next six months?
  • Is there anything this colleague does that you’d like more people on the team to copy?
  • Is there anything else you’d like this colleague to know?

After a short project, you might only send the first three: start, stop, keep. They fit on one phone screen, and people can answer them on the way out of the retro meeting.

Start with a ready-made 360 evaluation
Add these peer questions to a 17-question template that already covers leadership, communication and collaboration.

360-degree peer feedback questions for holistic performance reviews

Picture a 360 on Rosa, a regional sales manager. She rates herself, her boss rates her, her reps rate her, and so do the other regional managers. Only that last group has split a territory with her or covered her accounts during a vacation. Your 360-degree peer feedback questions should stay on that ground.

Rater groupWhat they see bestExample question
SelfWhat they meant to do, and how hard it wasHow well did you meet the goals you set at the start of this cycle?
ManagerWhether results landed and priorities heldHow well does this employee prioritize work that supports team goals?
PeersWhat it’s like to share a deadline with themHow reliably does this colleague deliver on shared commitments?
Direct reportsWhether they know what’s expected of themHow clearly does this person explain what’s expected of you?
Cross-functional partnersHow fast the other team gets answersHow easy is it to get what you need from this person’s team?

Say Rosa gives herself a 5 on coaching. Her reps give her a 3, and the other regional managers give her a 4.5 on collaboration. None of those numbers means much alone. Together they say she’s a great partner to her peers, and her own reps would like more of her time.

A few peer questions that sit well inside a 360:

  • How well does this person work with peers outside their own team? (rating)
  • How well does this person balance their own goals with what the wider team needs? (rating)
  • How would you rate this person’s willingness to share knowledge with peers? (rating)
  • How well does this person handle conflict with colleagues at the same level? (rating)
  • How much do you trust this person to follow through on cross-team commitments? (rating)
  • What’s one thing this person could do to be a better partner to peers? (open-ended)

Direct reports need their own questions about the people who manage them, and a manager evaluation form gives them that. Once you’re running reviews for several departments at the same time, the spreadsheet version stops working. Somebody ends up copying comments between tabs at midnight. With 360-degree feedback software, each rater group stays separate and their views land in one report.

How Embassy Suites found its review gaps
One short survey across four properties showed where performance reviews and employee empowerment fell short.

How to write an effective peer review questionnaire?

State the purpose at the top
Say Kim is reviewing a teammate and has heard the scores might feed into raises this year. She’ll soften everything. If the form says up front that it’s for development only, she might write what she saw. So the purpose goes at the top of the form, before any question.

Pick two or three competencies
A software team might settle on collaboration and code quality as its competencies for the cycle, and two or three is plenty. The client services team down the hall cares more about responsiveness, since that’s what their customers notice first.

Ask about observable behavior
Think about Ravi’s teammates. After a month, any of them could answer “How often does this colleague share updates before a deadline?” None of them can answer “How committed is this colleague?” without guessing. Questions about behavior someone could have watched get honest answers.

Use one scale throughout
Mixing scales trips people up. Picture a reviewer on question 9 who’s been rating frequency, and question 10 suddenly switches to agreement. Half the people filling it in won’t notice, and their 5s now mean something different from everyone else’s.

Add one open question per competency
Each competency gets one open-ended question. A 2 on communication tells the employee there’s a problem. The comment underneath tells them it’s the 11 p.m. reports with no summary.

Choose three to five reviewers
Three to five reviewers is a good range, as long as they work with the person every week. With only two, the employee can usually guess who wrote what. With nine, you’ll read “sometimes late to meetings” nine times.

Test with a few colleagues first
Two or three colleagues get the survey a few days early. One of them will stop at question 6 and ask what “cross-functional” means. Good. You can fix it before 200 people see it.

You’ve probably seen bad peer data. Everyone’s a 4. Every comment says “great to work with.” Usually the cause is simple: the peer review questionnaire ran too long, or it didn’t feel safe.

A word on scales. People remember how often a thing happens, so frequency scales work for behavior. For trust, agreement scales tend to read more naturally.

Scale typeBest forFive-point labelsExample item
FrequencyHabits and behaviorsNever, Rarely, Sometimes, Often, AlwaysHow often does this colleague meet agreed deadlines?
AgreementTrust and impactStrongly disagree to Strongly agreeI can rely on this colleague to follow through.
QualityWork outputPoor, Fair, Good, Very good, ExcellentHow would you rate the quality of this colleague’s handoffs?

Wording can tilt answers too. “How well does this colleague handle stress?” assumes there’s stress. “How does this colleague respond when priorities change on a Monday morning?” lets the reviewer describe what happened. Familiarity is the other trap. Someone who shared one project with Ravi in March shouldn’t be guessing about his leadership, and a “Not observed” option lets them skip it.

Anonymity needs its own decision before launch. If you’re not sure how much protection your setup gives, this guide to anonymous surveys for employees explains where it tends to break down.

How to create a peer review survey with Sogolytics?

Start from a template or prompt
The starting point is a template or a prompt. Sogolytics 360 feedback includes templates for a 360 evaluation, a performance evaluation and a manager effectiveness survey, plus a question bank. Prefer a blank page? Type a goal like “peer feedback for a product team” into Create with AI and you’ll have a full draft in under 60 seconds.

Edit the AI-generated draft
Nothing in that draft is fixed. Every AI-generated question can be edited, replaced or removed, so this is the point where you’d paste in the peer feedback questions from this guide.

Set competencies and rater groups
Competencies and rater groups come after the questions. The competency library is there if you want it, and you can always write your own. For groups, you’d set up self, manager, peers, direct reports and cross-functional partners. Forget one? Adding it later doesn’t mean rebuilding the survey.

Import reviewer lists from HR systems
Reviewer lists don’t need retyping. They can come straight from HR systems such as Workday, BambooHR, ADP and SAP SuccessFactors. Invitations can go out through Slack or Microsoft Teams too, which is where a lot of people will see them.

Let Sogolytics handle anonymity
Anonymity is handled for you. Peer responses don’t carry names in the stored record. A rater group’s report also stays locked until enough people have answered, so a manager can’t work out which two peers said what.

Automate the reminders
Automated reminders chase the stragglers. Nobody, the employee included, can tell who has or hasn’t answered.

Read the results report
Results arrive as a report. It lists strengths and growth areas in order and shows where the employee’s self ratings differ from everyone else’s. Written comments come grouped into themes. Each cycle adds to a running record. By next spring you can see what changed since this one.

Sogolytics gives you two ways in. HR teams with a review process already in place usually start from a template and trim it. If you’re building one for the first time, describing what you need and editing the draft is often faster. You end up in the same place: one editable survey you send and track in one place.

Say you’re running peer reviews for a 40-person engineering group. You’d probably start from the 360 template and strip it back to collaboration and communication. The start, stop and keep questions go on the end. Reviewer lists come over from your HR system. Two weeks later, when the window closes, each engineer gets one report with grouped comments instead of a folder of forty text boxes.

Still comparing options? This roundup of 360 feedback tools and this guide to the best employee feedback tool cover what to check before you sign anything. Peer reviews run on the same employee survey software you’d use for engagement and pulse surveys. After two or three cycles, HR analytics lets you line teams up side by side.

Find out how often feedback leads to change
Only 1 in 10 U.S. employees say their feedback always leads to change; see what the other nine told us.

Conclusion

The best peer review questions are the plain, specific ones: how often, how clearly, what happened last Thursday. Keep your form short. A reviewer who can finish it on a Thursday afternoon will finish it, and one staring at 40 questions won’t. And book the follow-up chat before the next cycle opens, because comments get thinner every year nobody reads them. Sogolytics brings peer, self and manager feedback into one employee experience platform, with anonymity thresholds and themed reports, so the comments reach the employee in a form they can use.

Turn peer feedback into career growth
Pair 360 assessments with measurable goals and regular check-ins, so each review builds on the last one.

FAQs about peer review questions

What is the difference between peer feedback and a performance review?

Your manager owns the performance review, which is the formal assessment and is often tied to pay. Peer feedback is what the people at your level say about working with you. Most teams pass it to the manager as evidence, since it’s how they hear about the meeting they weren’t in.

How many questions should a peer review survey include?

For most teams it’s 10 to 15 questions, which takes most people under ten minutes. Reviewing five colleagues in one week is a different story. Drop it to 6 to 8 for those reviewers, or by form four you’ll be getting one-word answers.

Should peer review surveys be anonymous?

Yes, in most cases, since people hold back criticism of someone they’ll sit next to tomorrow. Trust is shaky, though: in the Sogolytics Experience Index EX Q2 2026, only 21% of employees were confident anonymous feedback stays anonymous. Insidesource ran anonymous surveys across nine global locations to get candid input, and you’ll want minimum group sizes in place before you promise the same.

SHARE:

See what your feedback data is already telling you. Request a Demo

Client

Company Size

Industries

Customer Since

Read more

Typical Rave Review

Description